Any policies related to immigration have dealt almost exclusively with who should be allowed in, who can stay and who should go. When it comes to integration, the policy has been one of no policy.
President George W. Bush's accomplishments on immigration
reform fell well short of the comprehensive plan that he and others envisioned.
Yet the Bush administration did more than any other in modern history to lay
the groundwork for a much-needed immigrant integration policy. The Obama
administration must now use that beginning to build a bolder immigrant
integration policy - an immigrant policy that stands alongside our immigration
policy.
The federal government hasn't paid much attention to
immigrant integration in recent history. Any policies related to immigration
have dealt almost exclusively with who should be allowed in, who can stay and
who should go. When it comes to integration, the policy has been one of no
policy. The closest departures from a federal laissez-faire approach are
symbolic gestures, like resolutions affirming the primacy of English and
speeches about the importance of becoming American punctuated by fist pounding.
Under Bush's watch, the federal government, through the U.S.
Office of Citizenship, started very quietly to do something about immigrant
integration. Created when the Department of Homeland Security took over the
nation's immigration apparatus in 2003, the Office of Citizenship has helped
overhaul the citizenship test, publish preparation materials for the
citizenship test in multiple languages, and created a Web site, www.welcometoUSA.gov, that contains
information about everything from how to find an English language class to where
to volunteer to help immigrants integrate.
But the Office of Citizenship has been working all too
quietly. Rather than merely promoting citizenship and American civic identity,
the office ought to implement initiatives that foster a form of integration
that is mutually beneficial to immigrants and their adoptive country.
The Office of Citizenship should begin by helping immigrants
learn English. If there is one thing on which people on all sides of the
immigration debate agree, then it is that learning English is highly desirable.
Though all evidence points toward high levels of English language acquisition
over time, those who can't speak English suffer from diminished earning power,
have a tougher time being involved in their children's lives, and can't fully
participate in life in the United States. But English language classes are
notoriously over-enrolled, and good teachers are hard to come by. The Office of
Citizenship ought to make grants available for more classes and teacher training
to local government and nongovernmental organizations.
The Office of Citizenship can also help immigrants better
use the skills they bring with them. Some have called for an immigration policy
that favors the highly skilled, not realizing that we already have a sizable
skilled immigrant population. The problem is that these people can't get the
kinds of jobs they were trained to do. The Migration Policy Institute's
National Center on Immigrant Integration estimates that 1.3 million
college-educated immigrants are unemployed or underemployed in jobs like
dishwasher, taxi driver and security guard because U.S. employers do not
recognize foreign credentials. This tragic waste of skills hurts both
immigrants and our economy. The Office of Citizenship can help create a program
that translates foreign credentials for employers so that the nation's skilled
newcomers fulfill their potential in the labor market.
Finally, far too many immigrants fall prey to scams
perpetrated by individuals who promise to expedite their citizenship, find them
jobs and help them buy a home. These scams undermine trust between immigrants
and American institutions and are corrosive to integration. The Office of
Citizenship should develop programs that educate immigrants about their legal rights
and the potential threat of scams.
The Office of Citizenship is not a substitute for mechanisms
that drive integration, like good schools and anti-discrimination laws. Nor
should federally led integration efforts impose an ethnically chauvinistic version
of American identity, something that the Office of Citizenship has been careful
to avoid. But our nation of immigrants must have a bolder immigrant policy; one
that promotes integration not by passively encouraging it, but by providing the
tools that foster integration that is good for both immigrants and their new
home.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.