Sooner or Later -- and Probably Sooner -- Mexicans Are Going to Lose One of the Few Things They Have Left to Brag About: Their Soccer Dominance Over the United States.
It's hard to overstate what a blow this would be to Mexicans' collective psyche. But the rise of U.S. soccer is equally galling to people in other countries, who feel the United States is crashing the only party it doesn't already preside over.
Barack
Obama and a number of his cabinet members are only the second-most prominent
American team to descend on Mexico this week (the U.S. president traveled to
Guadalajara for the annual "Rodney Dangerfield summit," where Canada
and Mexico try to get some respect from their disinterested neighbor). Most
Mexicans are paying far more attention to the visit of a different delegation
from north of the Rio Grande, the U.S. national soccer team that takes on Mexico
in a crucial World Cup qualifying match at Mexico City's imposing Aztec Stadium
on Wednesday.
No
matter how bad things were at any given time, and no matter how powerless their
country appeared in the shadows of the colossus to the north, Mexicans used to
count on being able to trounce the gringos at soccer, which kind of made up for
everything else. The United States, which for decades failed to qualify for any
World Cup, did not beat Mexico once in the world's most popular sport between
1934 and 1980.
I grew
up in Mexico, and I can tell you: Games in the 1970s and '80s were so one-sided
they were painful to watch. Think the U.S. "dream team" taking on ... well,
Mexico, at basketball. Back then, the disparity in playing levels between the countries
was so great that I can recall feeling like Pelé when playing against Americans
my age at summer camp, even though I was nothing exceptional back home.
All that
has changed, of course, as the popularity of soccer exploded in the United
States, at least as a youth activity. In the last two decades, the U.S.-Mexico
rivalry for regional supremacy has become one of the fiercest in all
international soccer. And the United States has gained the upper hand more
recently in head-to-head matchups, though it has yet to win in Mexico City. Ever.
Which is
why Wednesday's match is huge. Only three countries from the Caribbean, Central
American, and North American regions will qualify for next year's World Cup in
South Africa (a fourth could sneak in, but I will spare you the details).
Despite an impressive win against the Americans in New York last month, Mexico
has been floundering in this round of World Cup qualifying matches, losing to
the likes of Costa Rica and Honduras. The Americans are doing far better, and
there is much anxiety in Mexico that in this year of epochal plagues (severe
U.S. recession + swine flu virus = GDP plummeting at a more than 10 percent
rate last quarter, and that's not even mentioning the drug wars) the gringos
could finally conquer "El Tricolor" in Mexico City, a trauma that
could jeopardize Mexico's ticket to the World Cup.
It's
hard to overstate what a blow this would be to Mexicans' collective psyche. But
the rise of U.S. soccer is equally galling to people in other countries, who
feel the United States is crashing the only party it doesn't already preside
over. Soccer, after all, is the only form of global pop culture not made or
dominated by the USA. Take kids from Mexico, Ghana, Germany, and Japan, and all
the things they will have in common—English possibly, music, movies,
consumer brand allegiances—will likely be American. Except, that is, for
soccer. Throw an American kid in the mix, and he is likely to be the only one
to draw a blank as the others express dismay at Portuguese forward Cristiano
Ronaldo's $133.5 million transfer fee from Manchester United to Real Madrid.
But if
international soccer is the sole threat to American cultural hegemony, the
United States has become the sport's China. People around the world chuckled at
Americans' claims during the run-up to the 1994 World Cup (held in the United
States) that their country would soon become a true player in the world's most
popular sport. They laughed at Deng Xiaoping in the mid-1980s, too, when he
announced he was going to open up and modernize China's economy.
Much
like China, the United States has a vast labor force to tap into (young soccer
players, that is, straining the analogy). Most of them seem to grow up watching
football—American football!—on TV, retarding the development of a higher-caliber
professional U.S. league. But soccer has for some time now ranked as the most
popular sport for little kids in the country to play.
Talk to
Mexicans about U.S. soccer, and the China analogy seems apt. The Americans, you
hear from anxious fans, are relentless and disciplined; there are so many of
them playing; and they are so organized in how they go about developing their
national strategy. Their progress is inexorable!
And like
China, the United States has had to develop as an export-driven market for its
top products, given the modest size of its domestic market. About half the
American players who take to the field Wednesday play for clubs in European
leagues (these national teams, like the U.S. basketball dream team, are
essentially all-star squads whose players come together to play other countries
from their respective club teams). The U.S. domestic professional league, Major
League Soccer (MLS), has proven adept at developing young talent, but top
American prospects can earn a lot more money in Europe.
It might
seem counterintuitive, but it is the relative weakness of its domestic league
that has helped the United States close the gap with Mexico. The U.S. neighbor
to the south has one of the richest professional leagues outside Europe, so far
fewer of its players feel the need to play overseas. Except for a handful of
top prospects, Mexicans can earn as much playing at home, where the food is
better. The typical payroll for a Mexican club team might be three or four
times greater than that of an MLS team, typically no more than $3 million.
Meanwhile, the richest European clubs in Spain and England boast payrolls
almost 100 times greater. Indeed, you can buy an entire MLS franchise for less
than what Real Madrid had to fork over to sign Cristiano Ronaldo.
But for
Mexico, stuck in a familiar purgatory between low-cost competition (as in the
real China, U.S. soccer) and high-value European leagues, long-term trends are
ominous. Fewer of its national team players are exposed to the same fast-paced
level of play that their American opponents are forced to compete in.
What
irritates Mexicans—even more than the fact that Americans are overtaking
them at their own sport—is that this could happen without most Americans
caring.
All of
this leaves Mexicans on the U.S. side of the border, and second-generation
Mexican-Americans (presumably including some fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan),
feeling conflicted when Mexico and the United States take to the field. And
that's OK, notwithstanding the ranting of anti-immigrant folks who have
allergic breakouts at the sight of fans rooting on Mexico when it plays the
United States in Los Angeles or Chicago, an occurrence often cited to support
the proposition that Mexican immigrants aren't assimilating like previous
waves of arrivals did.
(That,
by the way, is nonsense. Had mass sports been around back in 1850 and an Irish
team come over to play soccer against the Americans in New York or Boston, I'm
sure there would have been plenty of green flags in the stands. Loyalty to one's
new country is a good thing, but disloyalty to one's childhood sports teams is
pretty despicable.)
Don't be
offended, but I myself may be rooting for "El Tri" Wednesday, because my
boyhood soccer roots are in Mexico. It's not for lack of patriotism, really. If
the two countries ever go to war again, I'll be on the American side. But when
it comes to fútbol, I feel like
Mexico should get to hold onto at least that.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.