With the economy the way it is, you'd expect lots of husbands and wives to be at each other's throats. But the conventional wisdom is wrong. This recession is so bad that you can count divorce lawyers among those professions that have taken a hit.
Can't stand your boring husband? Thinking of calling it
quits? Well, you should have mustered the nerve to leave him well before this
economic crisis. Now you might not be able to afford to live without him,
literally.
It's a well-known fact that financial woes are the biggest cause of marital
spats. With the economy the way it is, you'd expect lots of husbands and wives
to be at each other's throats. But the conventional wisdom is wrong. This
recession is so bad that you can count divorce lawyers among those professions
that have taken a hit.
That's good news, right? People are now forced to stay together and work things
out. Well, not if history tells us anything. The Depression also saw a decline
in the divorce rate, but, according to marriage historian Stephanie Coontz,
incidents of domestic violence and outright family desertion went up.
In any case, despite the fact that divorce can cause all sorts of emotional and
financial turmoil, its statistical decline isn't as positive a social indicator
as one might think. As economist David Friedman has written, divorce is
actually a reflection of "an increase in the range of choice available to
individuals," and a high divorce rate and the general weakening of
marriage "are bad things only to the extent that they reflect a failure of
our institutions and expectations to adjust completely to new
circumstances."
In other words, in more traditional days, in which social changes occurred more
slowly, we all shared a general idea as to what marriage was and how it
functioned. From an economic standpoint, we all understood how the marital
division of labor worked. But in a rapidly changing society, it's harder to
figure out what kind of arrangement we should make with our spouses. Such
changes as the entrance of large numbers of women into the workplace and the
mechanization or outsourcing of household duties (from washing clothes to
curing bacon) undermined that tradition.
As the basic marriage deal has shifted, our notions and ideals haven't shifted
with it, and the disconnect explains the astronomical divorce rate in
contemporary America.
We haven't figured out a new marriage model that takes into account the greater
range of choices for both women and men.
This fits right into the fact that we're divorcing less in hard times. In the
context of this recession, we have fewer choices, and fewer choices means we're
back to a good fit with the marriage model of old. Still -- and a little
paradoxically -- the fact that there are untraditional marriages may also be
helping husbands and wives withstand some of the emotional and financial stress
of economic hard times. During the Depression, the ego blow to a man who lost
his job caused marital problems. Today, if a man loses his job -- and his wife
is the breadwinner -- it's less likely to create as much unhappiness.
If it's distasteful to you to look at marriage in economic terms, then it might
be easier to consider the economics of divorce. Not only are there attorney's
fees to be paid, but the value of the two biggest assets of most marriages -- a
home and a retirement plan -- has diminished dramatically. Faced with the
prospect of halving their shrunken assets, many couples are deciding to stick
it out a while.
A recent survey conducted by the Institute
of Divorce Financial Analysts
-- who knew? -- found that 68% of its members "have seen clients who could
not afford to get divorced because of recession-related financial
problems."
So even as most of us are looking forward to happier days of an economic
recovery, there must be a number of Americans who are waiting patiently to be
able to afford to experience the pain and suffering of divorce. You've heard of
the pent-up desire and aspiration that are released after times of war? That's
why we get such phenomena as baby booms. When this economic recovery finally
arrives, prepare yourselves for a boom of an entirely different sort.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.