Fearful of being placed on a target list by the government, most Argentinians fled or kept silent during those terrifying years. But Raul Alfonsin did not, loudly condemning the military government and offering help to families seeking information on their missing loved ones.
Few outside of Argentina remember him, but a good
man died yesterday. Raul Alfonsin was the first democratically elected
president of the Argentine
Republic after seven
years of military rule in which over 10,000 Argentinians were
"disappeared" by the military in a "Dirty War" against
leftist guerrillas.
The guerrilla groups, of whom the most prominent were the
Montoneros, were active throughout the 1970s, and they were deadly. Anyone in
the military, law enforcement, industry or finance risked being kidnapped or
killed. The guerrillas bombed police stations, military barracks and apartment
buildings. They were subversives whose ranks included members of normally
peaceful occupations: priests, journalists, social workers, students, teachers.
No one seemed able to discern who was a nonviolent leftist and who was secretly
a violent revolutionary, and unrest spread throughout the country, threatening
to devolve into outright civil war. Some Argentinians considered the Montoneros
to be idealists, but Raul Alfonsin, a member of the centrist Radical party,
never did. He condemned their cruelty and destruction.
In 1976, a military junta took control of the country and
set about eradicating the guerrillas. The counterterrorist measures taken were
of a brutality and magnitude that the country had never seen. The military kidnapped
people it suspected of being involved in terrorism, secreting them away to
hidden detention centers where they would be interrogated and tortured. Most of
those kidnapped were killed, in some cases by being drugged and pushed alive
out of airplanes. Mothers, fathers and relatives of people who were disappeared
would go to police stations and ministries and courtrooms seeking information
on those who had gone missing - only to be told that no one had any information
to give.
Fearful of being placed on a target list by the government,
most Argentinians fled or kept silent during those terrifying years. But Raul
Alfonsin did not, loudly condemning the military government and offering help
to families seeking information on their missing loved ones.
In 1983, Argentina
finally ousted the military dictators and held genuine elections. No one
expected Raul Alfonsin, whose Radical party had never enjoyed much public
support, to win. But Alfonsin did win. He inherited a country beset by debt,
inflation and bitter memories. Argentinians had high hopes that he could pull
them out of the morass.
Alfonsin wanted to demonstrate to everyone that Argentina was
once again a country ruled by laws, and he undertook two important things to
put the Dirty War to rest: he assembled a commission to investigate the
thousands of disappearances, and he put the leaders of the military junta on
trial. Argentinians and observers around the world were shocked by the testimony
of survivors, who gave accounts of beatings, electrocution and extrajudicial
killings. A list of the missing was compiled and came to over 10,000. The
generals were sentenced to prison (as were surviving guerrilla leaders), and Argentina tried
to return to normal.
But the fight between extreme left and extreme right in Argentina
persisted, albeit less violently. Rightists accused leftists of staging the
trials of the generals as revenge for having been defeated on the battlefield.
Leftists accused the centrists of going too easy on yesterday's torturers and
killers. Alfonsin faced rebellions by military fascists and denunciations by
neo-Stalinists.
Ultimately, as luck would have it, Alfonsin wound up stumbling
as a leader for a more mundane and common reason: the economy worsened. He had
inherited a budgetary disaster, and Argentinians were willing to be patient
while he attempted to address it. In the end, however, Alfonsin shied away from
making the choices necessary to set the country on a sustainable economic
course, and inflation soared to 200 percent a month. Investment died out almost
entirely, as Argentinians devoted all their economic energy to preserving what
capital they could salvage. By 1989, Alfonsin had been voted out, and no one
seemed to have anything kind to say about him.
Politics is unforgiving and unfair, and often scoundrels who
have a run of economic good luck are remembered with undue fondness. Juan Peron
subverted Argentine democracy in the 1940s and 50s, but he remains beloved by
many Argentinians for having raided the national coffers showing everyone a
good time. Raul Alfonsin erred on the side of fiscal timidity, but the economy
wound up crushing him. His bravery and decency on more fundamental questions -
his adherence to morality and legality in country that had been swept up in
evil and illegality - were insufficiently acknowledged and quickly forgotten
while he was in power.
But in the years after, people came to appreciate once again
what he had done for Argentina
and human rights. When a traumatized nation most desperately needed an upright
head of state, Alfonsin proved to be the most upright of men.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.