Parents who can afford the fees ought to contribute...But all leagues should make clear that children are still welcome even if their families don’t have the money.
This year’s Little League World Series, which began on Friday, is a lavish,
nationally televised American sporting event. At the site of the series in South Williamsport, Pa.,
there is a tent for the tournament’s corporate sponsors to show off their
products, an instant-replay system to decide close calls and a perfectly
groomed, two-stadium baseball complex.
For all of the tournament’s seductive gloss, Little League was born in
poverty. In 1938, Carl E. Stotz, a Williamsport
oil company clerk, lost his job when the business shut down the plant where he
worked. As Stotz explained in his 1992 autobiography, “A Promise Kept,” when he
wasn’t working the odd job, he --at the urging of two baseball-crazy young
nephews --devoted much of his time to planning the very first Little League.
And when he organized the first games in 1939, knowing firsthand how tough
the times were, he refused to charge parents for the privilege of having their
children in his league. He relied on donations from local businesses instead.
By the early 1950s, Stotz had turned Little League into an international
organization, and he enshrined his no-fee policy as an official rule. Even
though Stotz eventually broke with Little League after a bitter fight with the
organization’s board, his rule remains. You can find it in on page 39 of this
year’s 88-page Little League rule book.
“At no time should payment of any fee be a prerequisite for participation in
any level of the Little League program,” the rule reads in capital letters.
Although the rule permits individual leagues to request a fee of parents, “it
is recommended that no fee be collected.”
The rule may come as a shock to parents who signed up their children to play
Little League this year. Families routinely are required to pay fees that can
range from $10 to, in one New York
City league, $250 per child.
I examined registration forms from more than 400 Little League organizations
around the country, and I found only a handful of leagues that do not charge a
fee. Most of the fees were around $100. I could not find a single registration
form disclosing the fact that a fee was optional. Several suggested the fee was
mandatory.
“Any forms received without payment will be rejected,” reads the
registration form for a league in Fair
Lawn, N.J.
Officials at Little League headquarters in Pennsylvania said plainly that the rule
remains very much in effect. But Little League is a decentralized organization,
and in practice, local leagues are free to set their own budgets and mandate
fees. Most leagues need tens of thousands of dollars each year to cover the
costs of facilities, uniforms, equipment and field maintenance. In the Southern California league in which I have long coached,
the $125 fee does not cover all expenses. Our league has to solicit donations
to balance its books.
But as a condition of their charters, individual leagues are required to
honor all the rules. It would be in Little League’s interests to advertise the
rule widely. The organization faces competition from other sports and other
youth baseball programs. While these programs sometimes offer financial
assistance to poorer families, the promise of free baseball should give Little
League a competitive advantage.
Parents who can afford the fees ought to contribute. Leagues such as mine
should even consider raising fees to cover the true costs of their programs.
But all leagues should make clear that children are still welcome even if their
families don’t have the money. Parents and guardians who don’t pay should be
strongly urged to volunteer their time, as the Little League rule book
suggests.
And young ballplayers should feel free to remind their parents and Little
League officials that there is no financial excuse for keeping them off the
field. To insist on enforcing the rule is to fulfill the promise of the
Depression-era clerk who made free Little League the right of every child.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.