While Iran makes headlines for President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's incendiary remarks and its nuclear showdown with the United States, Iranian students are developing an international reputation as science superstars.
In 2003, administrators at Stanford
University's Electrical
Engineering Department were startled when a group of foreign students aced the
notoriously difficult Ph.D. entrance exam, getting some of the highest scores
ever. That the whiz kids weren't American wasn't odd; students from Asia and
elsewhere excel in U.S.
programs. The surprising thing, say Stanford administrators, is that the
majority came from one country and one school: Sharif University of Science and
Technology in Iran.
Stanford has become a favorite destination of Sharif grads. Bruce A. Wooley,
a former chair of the Electrical Engineering Department, has said that's
because Sharif now has one of the best undergraduate electrical-engineering
programs in the world. That's no small praise given its competition: MIT,
Caltech and Stanford in the United States,
Tsinghua in China and Cambridge in Britain.
Sharif's reputation highlights how while Iran
makes headlines for President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's incendiary remarks and its
nuclear showdown with the United
States, Iranian students are developing an
international reputation as science superstars. Stanford's administrators
aren't the only ones to notice. Universities across Canada
and Australia, where visa
restrictions are lower, report a big boom in the Iranian recruits; Canada has seen
its total number of Iranian students grow 240 percent since 1985, while
Australian press reports point to a fivefold increase over the past five years,
to nearly 1,500.
Iranian students from Sharif and other top schools, such as the University of Tehran and the Isfahan University of
Technology, have also become major players in the international Science
Olympics, taking home trophies in physics, mathematics, chemistry and robotics.
As a testament to this newfound success, the Iranian city of Isfahan recently hosted the International
Physics Olympiad--an honor no other Middle Eastern country has enjoyed. That's
because none of Iran's
neighbors can match the quality of its scholars.
Never far behind, Western tech companies have also started snatching them
up. Silicon Valley companies from Google to
Yahoo now employ hundreds of Iranian grads, as do research institutes
throughout the West. Olympiad winners are especially attractive; according to
the Iranian press, up to 90 percent of them now leave the country for graduate
school or work abroad.
So what explains Iran's
record, and that of Sharif in particular? The country suffers from many serious
ills, such as chronic inflation, stagnant wages and an anemic private sector,
thanks to poor economic management and a weak regulatory environment.
University professors barely make ends meet--the pay is so bad some must even
take second jobs as taxi drivers or petty traders. International sanctions also
make life difficult, delaying the importation of scientific equipment, for
example, and increasing isolation. Until recently, Iranians were banned from
publishing in the journals of the Institute for Electrical and Electronics
Engineers (IEEE), the industry's key international professional association.
They also face the indignity of often having their visa applications refused
when they try to attend conferences in the West.
Yet Sharif and its ilk continue to thrive. Part of the explanation, says
Mohammad Mansouri, a Sharif grad ('97) who's now a professor in New York, lies
in the tendency of Iranian parents to push their kids into medicine or
engineering as opposed to other fields, like law. Sharif also has an extremely
rigorous selection process. Every year some 1.5 million Iranian high-school
students take college-entrance exams. Of those, only about 10 percent make it
to the prestigious state schools, with the top 1 percent generally choosing
science and finding their way to top spots such as Sharif. "The selection
process [gives] universities like Sharif the smartest, most motivated and
hardworking students" in the country, Mansouri says.
Sharif also boasts an excellent faculty. The university was founded in 1965
by the shah, who wanted to build a topnotch science and technology institute.
The school was set up under the guidance of MIT advisers, and many of the
current faculty studied in the United States
(during the shah's era, Iranians made up the largest group of foreign students
at U.S. schools, according
to the Institute
of International Education).
Another secret of Sharif's success is Iran's high-school system, which
places a premium on science and exposes students to subjects Americans don't
encounter until college. This tradition of advanced studies extends into
undergraduate programs, with Mansouri and others saying they were taught
subjects in college that U.S.
schools provide only to grad students.
Several Sharif alumni point to one other powerful motivator. "When you
live in Iran
and you see all the frustrations of daily life, you dream of leaving the
country, and your books and studies become a ticket to a better life,"
says one who asked not to be identified. "It becomes more than just
studying," he says. "It becomes an obsession, where you wake up at 4
a.m. just to get in a few more hours before class."
Iran's
success, in other words, is also the country's tragedy: students want nothing
more than to get away the moment they graduate. That's a boon for foreign
universities and tech firms but a serious source of brain drain for the Islamic
republic. There simply are not enough quality jobs for graduates in Iran, says Ramin Farjad Rad, another Sharif grad
('97) who's now an executive at Aquantia in Silicon Valley.
What's worse, star students who stay in Iran and try to launch businesses
complain that predatory government officials demand a cut of their profits or
impose unnecessary obstacles. Thus many Iranians who can't make it to the West
head to Dubai
instead. As one Sharif grad in the Persian Gulf
port city puts it, "Here, our education is properly valued. We are given
freedom to succeed. In Iran,
we are blocked."
Such frustrations augur ill for Iran's future. True, it's produced
a startling number of top students in recent years. And the country's history
is rich with achievement, featuring Avicenna (also known as Ibn Sina), the
medieval world's greatest scientist; Muhammad al-Khwarizmi, the ninth-century
inventor of the mathematical algorithm (the basis of computer science), and
Omar Khayyam, the famed mathematician and astronomer. That's a fine legacy. But
unless the Islamic republic changes directions soon, all of that history and
potential could be squandered.
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.