But for even a fragile peace to hold in Baghdad, it's important for Obama officials to understand what has not changed since Bush led the charge.
One day in Iraq,
a friend picked me up from the house in Baghdad's
Mansur district and took me to the Shaab district of east Baghdad. We drove past checkpoints manned by
"Awakening" militias created by the Americans to counteract the
Shiite-led Mahdi Army militia. My friend, a Shiite himself from Shaab, put a
tape in the cassette player. "Now we are the Mahdi Army," my friend
laughed, as the singing started. The songs praised populist anti-American
cleric Moqtada al-Sadr and the Iraqi militia loyal to him, which frequently
blew up or kidnapped Americans and other foreigners. Later, Mahdi Army members
asked my friend suspiciously if I was a foreigner (yes) who drank alcohol or
slept with Iraqi women (no). The Mahdi Army had wanted to kidnap me, and had
hoped to find the proper pretext to justify it in my immorality. Fortunately,
I'm still here.
This was December, month three of my last trip to Iraq. Much has
changed in the country since then, and President Obama will surely change
things even more. But for even a fragile peace to hold in Baghdad, it's important for Obama officials
to understand what has not changed since Bush led the charge. On the list: the
love the Shiites feel for Sadrists, the Mahdi Army, and the extensive social
services they provide. Even though the Mahdi Army has gone to ground, they
still exist--and await Sadr's orders impatiently. In a fissiparous and fragile Iraq, these
militias are here to stay. Let me take you on a Sadrist-guided tour.
Mustafa Mosque
The Mustafa Mosque in Ur
was a Baath party office until Sadrists took it over. By 2006 the Mahdi Army
had converted the mosque into a command center, launching arrests targeting
radical Sunnis and former Baathists. American and Iraqi forces then raided it,
(and the mosque's Sadrist imam fled to Qom,
Iran) but Abu
Hassan, assistant and caretaker of the mosque, remained behind to repair it.
Born in Sadr City
in 1972, Hassan is a muscular and voluble man who informally leads the Ur district. He was
always a Sadrist, he told me with a smile, and had followed Sadr's father,
Ayatollah Muhamad Sadiq al-Sadr, until he was killed in 1999. While repairing
the mosque, Abu Hassan maintained an office in an adjacent one-room structure.
There he sat on the floor behind a desk and received guests and supplicants.
Abu Hassan's office was rarely empty. On one of my visits I
found him distributing bags of clothes and rations to poor women in black abayat,
many from families displaced by Sunni militias, or related to Mahdi Army
martyrs. The Sadrist office gave these women such staples as milk, oil, rice,
and sugar. Many still lived in tents in the nearby Shishan, or Chechen,
neighborhood, thus named because Iraqis thought Chechnya was very poor. The family
of an unmarried Mahdi Army martyr received 75,000 dinars a month (about $60),
as did the family of an arrested man. The family of a married Mahdi Army martyr
received twice as much. The Red Cross and Red Crescent helped such women as
well, said Hassan, but the Iraqi government did not.
Another time I visited Abu Hassan, his office was crowded.
Among those visiting him were two young men belonging to the Iraqi security
forces. One was a member of the Facility Protection Service, a government
militia that protected ministries and other Iraqi government offices but was
notoriously loyal to sectarian Shiite militias. The other man belonged to the
Iraqi National Guard. Both proudly told me they were also members of the Mahdi
Army. "We want you to know that most of the Sadrists are working for the
government," said the FPS member. They listed many men who had been killed
by Sunni militias. "I've been a soldier in the Iraqi National Guard for
three years," said his friend. "We saw that none of the political
parties or movements are working for the benefit of the people except this
movement. The Sadrists are devoting their time and effort to help Iraqi people.
I thought the best way to help the people is by joining them."
Several men were seated near them on the floor awaiting Abu
Hassan's arbitration services. He was to adjudicate a legal dispute over real
estate. "We can't reach the registration directorate," they told me,
because it was in Adhamiya, a Sunni stronghold. "We might get killed if we
go there," they added.
Abu Hassan's faithful assistant was a handsome young man
called Haidar. He sedulously did Abu Hassan's bidding, and was in charge of
feeding the guests and making tea for them. Haidar and his family had lived in
Abu Ghraib, west of Baghdad,
when in 2006 they were forced to leave. Radical Sunnis began killing the Shiite
clerics in Abu Ghraib, he explained. Although the area near Abu Ghraib is now
more stable because of the Awakening militia there, Haidar and his family, like
other Shiites, do not feel reassured. "The Awakening were with the terrorists
before, and they are the Awakening now."
The owner of the house he and his family now lived in was
that of a Sunni terrorist who had been expelled by the Sadrist movement. The
Sadrists also provided Haidar's family with rations. Haidar joined the Sadrist
movement soon after the American invasion, and is a member of the Mahdi Army.
"I don't think I'm able to go back," Haidar said of his old home.
Shurufi Mosque
The main Sadrist office for the area was in the Shaab
district, in the Shurufi Mosque. Abu Hassan took me there several times over
the course of my three months in Baghdad.
When I first visited in December, locals complained that the Americans had just
arrested four Mahdi Army men. I entered the mosque accompanied by Sheikh
Safaa's brother, another local leader who could vouch for me. Inside I met
Seyid Jalil Sarkhi al-Hassani, imam for Friday prayers since 2006. He had a
beard but no mustache, wore wire-framed glasses and a brown cloak. We met in a
green guest room that was his study. A large painting of Moqtada al-Sadr's
father hung on the wall. As he prepared to enter the mosque for the Friday
sermon he donned a white funeral shroud as Sadrists were wont to do,
symbolizing their readiness for martyrdom.
Inside the mosque was colored light, green, with a green
carpet on the floor. Straw mats were placed outside for the overflowing crowds.
I saw a pistol partially covered by one man's prayer carpet. Fluorescent lights
and fans hung down from the ceiling. The dome of the mosque had been destroyed
in 2006 by a suicide truck and was still not fully repaired. In one corner was
a large women's section surrounded by a tall curtain. Hundreds of men strolled
in. Many were fit young Mahdi Army members, wearing tracksuits. As they sat to
listen to the sermon, men would randomly stand up and shout a
"hossa," or war call, in hoarse voices--to which the audience would
respond, "Our God prays for Muhammad and his family!" One man called
for freeing the prisoners from American prisons. Another shouted, "Death
to spies and the Americans!" Other hossas I heard that day: "Death is
an honor for us, arrest is honor for us, resisting the Americans is honor for
us!" and "Pray for Sadr, release of all the arrested people, and in a
loud voice, death to the Americans and to their agents!"
As we left, several young men in the courtyard asked us to
join them for lunch. My friend later told me that one of them was a famous
local maker of roadside bombs, or IEDs, that targeted the Americans.
Washash
The streets of the majority Shiite Washash are unpaved dirt,
many flooded with water or sewage. Electric cables hang low from rooftops and
crisscross like old cobwebs. In Washash I saw more posters and banners hanging
up in honor of Sadr and his father than anywhere else in Baghdad. Behind the concrete walls, only one
road is left open for cars, and it is guarded by Iraqi soldiers. Elsewhere, a
few narrow paths allow pedestrians to enter one at a time.
Because it was so dangerous for outsiders, my driver, whose
cousin lived there, arranged for the head of the local tribal council to guide
us and guarantee my safety. A Sadrist himself, Sheikh Kazim introduced me to
the Mahdi Army men who surrounded us as we strolled through his neighborhood.
"We are helping the people who have been displaced from other cities
because of sectarianism," he said. "Some of the help is with stipends
or places to live. Also we are trying to provide gas and kerosene as much as we
can."
I met one man displaced from Dora. "They started
killing [Shiites] in their houses there," he said. "They did not get
my son because he was at his college." One month after fleeing to Washash
from Dora, he said, "The Americans and the Iraqi army blew up the door to
our house and they arrested us and some of our neighbors. We don't know
why."
As Sheikh Kazim walked down the street with me, we were soon
surrounded by throngs of Mahdi Army men and other residents of Washash
desperate to voice their anger. One man who served in the Iraqi army's special
forces for 23 years had recently had his home raided by the Iraqi army.
"They insulted me and my honor," he shouted at me. "I spent
eight years fighting in the war with Iran and a solider came to me
yesterday and called me the brother of a whore!"
The men spoke of the Iraqi army unit in charge of their area
much the way Sunnis spoke of the Iraqi police. "They are dealing with us
in a sectarian way," explained Kazim. "Most of the prisoners are
Shiites; most of the arrests are of Shiites."
We passed men wheeling in goods for sale on pushcarts, and
at an intersection I found a tractor the Sadrists had provided as a garbage
truck to clean the streets. A crowd of women in abayat sat by dozens of
colorful jerricans. They were waiting for kerosene that the Mahdi Army was
supposed to bring in.
I approached the women and was surprised by how eager they
all were to talk to me. "My dear," said an elderly woman with tribal
tattoos on her chin, "we don't have electricity, kerosene, or gas, and we
have been insulted. To whom should we complain?"
A younger woman told me she had been expelled from the
majority Sunni town of Mahmudiya
after two of her sons were murdered. She was left only with her daughters now.
"The terrorists killed my sons with a car bomb and the Mahdi Army are the
only ones who gave me a shelter. May god bless the Mahdi Army. Anyone who says
they are terrorists is lying."
The Sadrists led me through the market that had once served
the neighborhoods around Washash. We approached a narrow opening between the
walls that separated Washash from Mansur. Behind it was an Iraqi army
checkpoint. A soldier spotted me filming and began to approach. "He won't
dare come in," said one of the Mahdi Army men with me, "or we will
fuck him."
The Ministry of the Interior
At the Ministry of Interior the televisions in the lobby and
waiting room were tuned in to the Shiite religious channels. Shiite religious
music blared from radios of police vehicles. Shiite religious banners hung on
the Ministry of Interior while Shiite religious flags waved in the wind above
the nearby Ministry of Oil and other government buildings. It may have seemed
harmless, but it made Sunnis feel like they did not belong. It was a way of
letting them know that the state now belonged to the Shiites. And more than the
Shiites--there's a close relationship between the Mahdi Army and Iraqi police
in southern Baghdad.
There, where the Shiite districts are dominated by Sadrists, a police officer's
phone even has a Mahdi Army song as its ring tone. The Iraqi army, known to be
less sectarian, had actually come to blows with Shiite police in one local
checkpoint. According to one frustrated officer from the police unit, his
lieutenant colonel, called Majid, had asked him to free a Sunni prisoner and
collect $4,000 from his family. The man was innocent and the court had already
ordered his release. Majid in turn received a promotion. Kidnappings such as
this are a key source of revenue for the Mahdi Army.
But are the American-created militias really any less
problematic? Abu Hassan is suspicious of the Sunni Awakening militias. There is
an Awakening group in one neighborhood, he says, now led by a man who beheaded
hundreds of Shiites. "This is not logical."
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.