The issues of granting China membership
in the World Trade Organization and selling arms to Taiwan promise
to generate many headlines over the next year. These issues,
however, are linked in many ways that are not immediately apparent.
Assuming both China and Taiwan can join the global organization
-- as both seek to do -- WTO membership could advance the cause
of peace and stability in the Taiwan Straits as much as arms
sales.
Although it has received limited attention, trade and investment
are among the few bright spots in the Taiwan-China relationship.
Despite the constant threat of conflict, economic ties have
dramatically increased over the last decade.
According to Beijing's statistics, Taiwan is now China's fifth-largest
trading partner. Since 1987, trade between mainland China and
Taiwan has totaled almost $2 trillion; it grew at a 7 percent
annual rate in 1999.
Investment has also undergone similar growth. According to
statistics from Taiwan, businesses there have invested $14.4
billion spread over 22,000 projects in the mainland. Beijing's
statistics put the level of completed investment even higher:
$22.4 billion divided between 44,000 projects.
Despite the ongoing hostility, China is by far the leading
market for Taiwanese investment, claiming more than 40 percent
of Taiwan's total foreign investment.
This growth has not been unfettered. Direct trade between the
two is generally prohibited, with most commerce passing first
through Hong Kong.
Taipei has also screened Taiwanese investment in China. The
current Taiwanese government has argued that too much trade
and investment with the mainland could pose a security risk.
The newly elected Taiwanese president, however, has indicated
a willingness to explore liberalizing these restrictions.
This move to expand trade and investment could be boosted by
another international development that both Taipei and Beijing
are pursuing -- membership in the WTO.
China's high-profile campaign for WTO membership seems to be
in its final stages. Taiwan's effort is even more advanced,
with the necessary talks with WTO members essentially completed.
Acting through surrogates, however, China has attempted to
hold up Taiwan's membership, at least until Beijing is admitted.
Assuming that China refrains from last-minute maneuvers to
upset the apple cart, both China and Taiwan are likely to be
admitted to the WTO this year.
Although either Beijing or Taipei could take formal reservations
against the other to avoid complying with WTO provisions regarding
the ""other China, '' WTO provisions would likely
require liberalization of trade and economic ties over the Taiwan
Straits. Most current restrictions on Taiwan-China trade and
investment are incompatible with WTO requirements.
Thus, WTO membership could reinforce the move for liberalization
already afoot in Taiwan and encourage the new Taiwanese president
to lift existing restrictions. The almost certain result would
be still more trade and investment between Beijing and Taipei.
Expanded economic ties are not a panacea for tensions between
Taiwan and China. The relationship between Taipei and Beijing
is complex, and maintaining peace will also require military
and diplomatic steps and considerable ongoing U.S. involvement.
Mutual WTO membership and the expanded economic interaction
that it is likely to bring, however, could be an important step
toward comity. Already, trade and investment has created substantial
business interests in Taiwan and Mainland China in favor of
detente. Peace-minded leaders on both sides of the Taiwan Straits
see economic ties as an important element of a lasting strategy
to reduce tensions.
WTO membership itself also has an often-overlooked direct benefit
in this connection. If both Taiwan and China were WTO members,
the WTO could be a forum for direct communication on and adjudication
of economic and trade disputes. The current virtual absence
of direct ties often makes frank contact and negotiation difficult.
WTO membership would also provide Taiwan with something it
has long sought, a forum in which Taipei and Beijing could deal
as equals. Though again not a panacea, this would be a significant
step forward for cross-straits relations.
A dispute between Taiwan and China is widely seen as the likeliest
route to a new world war. There are, however, opportunities
to reduce tensions and make conflict less likely.
If the United States is willing to exercise leadership within
the WTO and Taiwan and China both behave responsibly, WTO membership
for Taipei and Beijing could be secured this year. This would
be just one step down the doubtlessly long and rocky road to
peace, but it is nonetheless an important step in the right
direction.
Mutual WTO membership for Taiwan and China and the expanded
economic ties it is likely to bring represent an opportunity
that should be grasped.
Copyright 2000, Journal of Commerce
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.