The keynote address at a typical hacker
convention is delivered by the "Wizened Security Guru," usually
an ex-CIA spook who wows the crowd with cloak-and-dagger tales.
If he's not available, then the honor may fall to the "Hot Young
Programmer," invariably a cocky coder who recounts his latest
"eureka!" moment. But at last weekend's third-ever Hackers on
Planet Earth convention, nicknamed H2K, the featured speaker
was a confessed techno-idiot, a man who denies ever having so
much as pressed an "ESC" key: Jello Biafra, ex-frontman for
punk provocateurs the Dead Kennedys.
Decked out in a "D.A.R.E. to Keep Kids Out of Church" T-shirt,
Biafra enraptured hundreds of hackers with a 90-minute diatribe
against, among other things, the World Trade Organization, the
Philadelphia police, "Al Gore, Inc.," USA Today and Taco Bell's
value meals. "Use the Internet to create a generation that sees
through corporate bullshit like never before!" he exhorted the
crowd at New York's Hotel Pennsylvania. "Don't hate the media;
become the media!" And though most audience members were not
yet in diapers when "Holiday in Cambodia" debuted, Biafra's
address was frequently punctuated by high-decibel applause and
"Preach on, brother!" shouts.
Biafra's star turn at H2K was a bombastic symbol of the computer
underground's growing zeal for political agitation -- whether
it be greeting would-be visitors to a hijacked Nike.com with
"Global Justice is coming -- prepare now!" while redirecting
them to an Australian labor rights site, or disabling the Chinese
government's censorware. Already adroit at rallying around their
persecuted peers, many hackers are now awakening to the world
beyond Internet Relay Chat. Ideological kin to the coalition
of anarchists, Teamsters and Earth Firsters who spearhead the
anti-globalization movement, these self-styled "hacktivists"
dream of furthering social justice while comfortably ensconced
behind their Linux workstations.
Just last weekend -- as about 100 hackers gathered for a "Cyber
Civil Disobedience" discussion at H2K -- a group calling itself
"Gforce Pakistan" defaced 11 pages belonging to the National
Oceanic Atmospheric Administration. The usual weather-related
pabulum was replaced with pleas for Kashmiri independence. "When
the people of Kashmir want to be independent, why not let them?"
the protesters wrote. "US, take some steps."
But even as the ranks of techno-pranksters on political missions
swell, a number of veteran hackers categorize such "protests"
as sloppy and counter-productive. "Ninety-five percent of it
is bullshit," says Andy Mueller-Maguhn, an associate of Germany's
Chaos Computer Club. "[The message] will be there for about
five minutes. Then we've got a police investigation. Then we've
got that Kevin Mitnick shit." In other words, more ammunition
for anti-hacker hysterics to demand get-tough measures, with
little to show for the sacrifice.
Critics of the strategy also question whether the defacers
are truly committed to fighting the good fight, or are more
interested in showing off their technical chops. "A lot of these
kids, they're like, 'Cool, I just hacked a Web page and got
my little political message up,'" says "Izaac," a cohost of
"Off the Hook," a weekly radio show produced by 2600, the hacker
quarterly. "Then you ask them what their message is, and they're
like, 'Huh?'" The majority of Web page vandals, he points out,
prefer to get their messages across with bawdy "yo' momma" jokes
rather than well-argued dissertations on Nike's labor policies.
The truth is that while the hacktivist slogan, "The revolution
will be digitized!" is certainly catchy, most techno-protestors
have yet to prove themselves anything more than pests. Disorganized
and occasionally reckless, many are content to deface Web pages
with "Break the Bank!" graffiti; they are not engaging in powerful
acts that might set the mandarins of globalization aquake in
their boots. And right now, with the underground so fractured,
and the hacktivist agenda so hazily defined, it's hard to imagine
these techno-activists having any appreciable impact on global
politics.
Though the word was recently coined, hacktivism can trace its
roots to the prankster counterculture of the 1960s. The hacker
ethos originated in the "Steal This Book!" culture-jamming hijinks
of the radical Youth International Party and Abbie Hoffman,
who pulled proto-hacking stunts by crafting payphone slugs.
And the early "phreakers," who used their technical acumen to
pilfer phone service, espoused the same anti-corporate beliefs
as the pepper-sprayed protesters of Seattle.
Greg Newby, a professor of information science at the University
of North Carolina, argues that many hacktivists also have a
bred-in-the-bone inclination toward social justice. Filled with
folks who wear the "misfit" label with not-so-subtle pride,
the underground is a come-as-you-are club. "Hackers have always
been blind to things like color and race and accent," he says.
"There might be some prejudice against people who don't type
fast, or have a slow connection, but we're blind to what is
very important to the other people in the world."
Yet the bulk of hacker activism has been narrowly focused on
pet causes. The "Free Kevin" movement, for example, which prevented