Friends of China both inside and outside
the Clinton administration are quick to assert that China's
accession to the World Trade Organization will also mean WTO
membership for Taiwan, as if the two actions were inevitably
linked. But this is wishful thinking. China has acted for years
to keep Taiwan out of the world trading system, and there are
no grounds for believing that Beijing, once itself a member,
will be any more hospitable to Taiwan.
On the contrary, there are grounds for expecting trouble. They
begin with China's poor record of keeping its trade promises.
Then there is Beijing's history of throwing up barriers in Taiwan's
path, despite the latter's strong trade credentials and efforts
at accommodating its giant neighbor.
Thus, to avoid formally challenging China, which claims sovereignty
over it, Taiwan in 1990 applied for admission to the world trading
system as a customs territory, not an independent country. A
similar formula had been used to bring Hong Kong into the trading
system in 1986. Ignoring this good-faith gesture, China has
acted through surrogates -- notably Hong Kong, since Beijing's
takeover there in 1997 -- to block the admission of Taiwan,
even though Taipei has diligently completed bilateral negotiations
with all of its trading partners.
The United States and other democratic countries have failed
to confront this obstructionism. When pressed about it, Clinton
administration officials cite an unwritten understanding they
have with Beijing that Taiwan will join the WTO once China is
a member. So confident are they that China will keep its word
that they routinely list Taiwan's joining the WTO among the
benefits of China's eventual membership, even though this unenforceable
understanding has no more status than a whispered promise, a
promise whose existence China has never squarely and publicly
acknowledged.
Recent reports in the Taiwanese press are not reassuring. They
cite unnamed Chinese sources who say that China might bar Taiwan's
entry by insisting on some last-minute deal-breaker, such as
a requirement that Taiwan change the name on its application
to acknowledge Beijing's sovereignty. Such a move would be not
only an affront to the United States, but also a blow to its
economic interests. Taiwan is, and is likely to remain, a much
better export market for the United States than China. Last
year, Americans sold $ 17.6 billion worth of exports to Taiwan
and only $ 12.6 billion to China; American farmers, in particular,
exported more than twice as much to Taiwan ($ 1.5 billion) as
they did to China ($ 750 million). And in the future, Taiwan
is much more likely than China to meet its commitments to opening
its market further.
If the administration were serious about securing Taiwan's
entry to the WTO, it would obtain a specific, public commitment
from China that Taiwan's application will be accepted simultaneously
with China's. Instead, there is a good chance that the diplomatic
maneuvering on this issue will occur late this year -- in the
last days of the Clinton administration, when the White House
is eager, perhaps overeager, to cement its legacy on China.
To make matters worse, by then, key Clinton personnel may already
have departed, creating a situation ripe for a mistake or a
last-minute Chinese deception.
Plainly, Congress alone can devise a solution binding on both
this president and his successor. And the means is at hand:
Congress should pass a law making Taiwan's admission to the
WTO a precondition for China's permanent normal trade relations
with the United States. Until such a statute can be passed,
meanwhile, Congress should make it clear to the Chinese through
lesser measures -- resolutions, letters, and public statements
-- that any duplicity regarding Taiwan would jeopardize China's
trade relations with the United States
Copyright 2000, The Weekly Standard
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.
Your tax-deductible gift will help bring promising new voices and ideas into our nation's discourse, and help shape the future of vital public policies.
Join the Conversation
Please log in below through Disqus, Twitter or Facebook to participate in the conversation. Your email address, which is required for a Disqus account, will not be publicly displayed. If you sign in with Twitter or Facebook, you have the option of publishing your comments in those streams as well.