Political Reform Program
 

Political Reform Blog

The latest updates from the Political Reform Program are posted below. Click on any headline for the complete item.

Hungry for IRV

Letter to the Editor published in the Los Angeles Daily News, by Linda Suh

IRV - Instant runoff voting, or, as I like to call it, "immediate rescue (for) voting." L.A. currently suffers tremendously from its inefficient election method. For example, only 6 percent of registered voters voted… more

July 19, 2007

State Republican Committee dumps winner-take-all policy

Rebuffing efforts by Mitt Romney loyalists, the Republican State Committee this week changed its policy of committing all the state's delegates to the winner of the presidential primary.

The winner-take-all policy had been championed by Romney backers -- including national committeeman Ron Kaufman -- when it came before a committee… more

July 13, 2007

Letter: Improve elections with rank system

In "Independents don't change system" [Opinion, June 25], Joshua Spivak warns that a third-party presidential candidacy's best hope is to play the spoiler, serving to elect a president who might otherwise have lost had he or she not thrown a hat in the ring. While this is usually the… more
July 5, 2007

Brown to set out plans to cede powers to parliament

Gordon Brown will today spell out his plans for reform of the House of Commons as he seeks to restore public trust in the political process.

In his first full statement to the Commons since becoming prime minister, he will reveal his intention to move power away from the… more

July 3, 2007

Doing away with election spoilers

We're hearing the word "spoiler" again in connection with a presidential election.

Admirers of former President George H.W. Bush have said all along that Ross Perot's third-party candidacy in 1992 took enough votes from Bush to allow Bill Clinton to win the presidency. It's clear that Ralph Nader kept… more

July 2, 2007

How IRV affects mudslinging campaigns

(op-ed by Steven Hill, published in the San Francisco Chronicle)

With all the controversy swirling around embattled San Francisco Supervisor Ed Jew regarding FBI investigations and his in-district residency, some have asked the question: How did this guy ever get elected? Ironically the answer reveals a new dynamic in… more

June 24, 2007

Tease for two

Have you stopped beating your spouse? Yes or no? No other response is acceptable.

Would you like being told that you must have a car, and must choose between a Ford and a Chevy? Or that you must profess a religion, and your only two choices are Jainism and Zoroastrianism?

If so,… more

June 21, 2007

Instant runoff voting is worth a look

(Editorial in the Daily Breeze) Local agencies can spend less on elections because the primary and runoff occur simultaneously, which would mean less voter fatigue.The last two elections supervised by the Los Angeles City Clerk's Office produced dismally low turnouts. Only 10 percent of registered… more

June 15, 2007

Los Angeles may vote for change

(Published in the Los Angeles Daily News) To entice Angelenos back to the polls after record-low turnouts in recent years, the city is mulling a host of changes, including new election dates, more mail-in voting and instant runoff voting. In this… more

June 13, 2007

Instant runoffs might be fix for voter fatigue

(Written by Steve Hymon, LA Times Staff Writer, with quote from Lynne Serpe)

Let's begin by agreeing that the Los Angeles City Council's Rules and Elections Committee is not exactly Comedy Central. That's not… more
June 11, 2007

LACCD Resolution: Saving Taxpayer Dollars Through Efficient, Democratic Elections

 

The following resolution was presented by Trustee Mona Field and passed by the Board of Trustees:

WHEREAS, The Los Angles Community College District election cycle and structure is legally tied to the City of Los Angeles; and

more
June 11, 2007

Council votes to change runoff election process

The Cary Town Council has given a thumbs up for Cary to be a pilot community for the Wake County Board of Elections Instant Runoff Voting Method for its municipal elections in November.

The decision came at Thursday night’s council meeting where Cherie Poucher, director of the Wake County Board of… more

May 25, 2007

Dozen seats to be won and lost on transfers

The final seats that decide the balance of power in the 30th Dáil will come down to the crucial but volatile system of vote transfers.Now that first counts are being completed, party strategists will be anxiously studying which candidates get second, third and lower preferences… more
May 25, 2007

`Yes' side to battle for voting reform

Supporters of a radical new way of electing Ontario politicians will today announce the formation of a Yes campaign for the Oct. 10 referendum.The move comes one day after the Liberal government released regulations for the vote that place no limits on how much any group can… more
May 24, 2007

Gimmicks to get out the vote

(Steve Wiegand's column in the Sacramento Bee refers to an event where director Steven Hill spoke)

Back when dinosaurs still roamed the Earth (January 1986), then-Secretary of State March Fong Eu decided to stage a contest to increase voter turnout.Eu's idea was to solicit catchy slogans from citizens, … more

May 24, 2007

Opportunity '08, a Brookings project, features white paper on IRV

Former GOP Congressman from Illinois, John Porter, recommends that the next President promote “instant runoffs” to help elect less partisan, more mainstream candidates and encourage more voters to go to the polls.

(Excerpt) Redistricting has resulted in an extraordinarily high number of “safe… more

May 21, 2007

Five Million for Six Percent

LOS ANGELES, CA – With barely six percent of voters coming to the polls on Election Day, Tuesday May 15, 2007 for an election that cost taxpayers $5 million to administer, the New America Foundation proposes eliminating the runoff election and… more

May 16, 2007

Bruins United finishes big

Bruins United won a decisive victory in the undergraduate student government elections Thursday night, taking eight of the 10 contested seats, including the office of the president.

In addition to the presidency, Bruins United won three commissioner positions and both vice president offices, as well as two of the… more

May 11, 2007

Green elected student president

Travis Green ‘08 won a close but decisive victory in the race for Student Body President on Tuesday night, defeating the four other candidates throughout eleven rounds of instant runoff voting. Green’s running mate Ian Tapu ‘08 took the vice presidency, completing a sweep for the pair’s “iGreen” campaign.… more
May 9, 2007

LA City Council members Huizar & Garcetti introduce motion on instant runoff voting

MAY 0 2 2007

MOTION: RULES & ELECTIONS COMMITTEE

Introduced by Councilmember Jose Huizar, Seconded by Councilmember Eric Garcetti

The City of Los Angeles currently uses a two-round runoff system to electits Mayor, City Attorney, City Council, and Controller. One election isheld in early March, and if no… more

May 2, 2007

France's Election Flaw

(This opinion piece was co-authored by Steven Hill and Guillaume Serina) What if the wrong candidate wins France's presidential election? If the wrong candidate were to win because of electoral fraud - stuffing of ballot boxes or rigging of votes - all… more
April 25, 2007

Ranked Choice Voting: Will California follow the Bay Area's lead?

The following event was sponsored by The Voices of Reform Project - Commonwealth Club

PANELISTS: John Arntz, Director, San Francisco Department of Elections Richard DeLeon, Ph.D., Professor of Political Science, San Francisco State University Rosalind Gold, Sr. Director of Policy, Research and Advocacy, NALEO Educational Fund… more

April 20, 2007

A Better Way to Vote

"The majority rules!" is one of the most frequently heard battle cries of American politics, but the reality is otherwise: Every year, in scores of state and local elections, no candidate wins a majority. That results in either costly runoffs or "winners" who in fact have been rejected by… more
April 19, 2007

Ontario will vote on MMP

If approved, the new system would be in place during the election expected in 2011, and it would end a way of voting that has existed in Ontario since before Confederation and which generally allows parties to command strong legislative majorities without obtaining the… more
April 16, 2007

IRV voting may advance in Vermont Senate

MONTPELIER – A Vermont Senate committee appears poised to narrowly approve a bill today calling for instant run-off voting for U.S. Senate and House seats, although the issue proved to be a controversial one during testimony Thursday.

The latest bill calling for a switch to the majority-rule form of electing… more

April 13, 2007

Lynne Serpe on KPCC's Airtalk with Larry Mantle

Instant Runoff Voting for L.A.? (Listen) A study released yesterday from the New America Foundation finds that runoff elections in Los Angeles result in higher costs to taxpayers and lower voter turnout. The Foundation proposes an electoral method known as… more
April 12, 2007

Warm Weather Party: The Review’s pick for ASSU Exec

For the 2007 ASSU Elections, make your first choice Brian Truebe and Folahan Olowoyeye of the Warm Weather Party, and your second choice Brett Hammond and Lakshmi Karra of Brett and Lakshmi.

The Warm Weather party is running on a pro-student-freedom and an anti-administration ticket. Their candidacy is motivated in… more

April 9, 2007

Corvallis to look at instant runoff system for elections

The Corvallis City Council voted unanimously Monday to support a state bill to allow local governments to choose an instant runoff system in elections for mayors or council members.

The council isn’t ready yet to switch to instant runoff voting, even for Planning Commission and Historic Resources Commission appointments. That… more

April 2, 2007

Better Elections with Instant Runoffs

With our current electoral laws, filling the vacancy created by Martin Meehan's departure from the House of Representatives might be as pleasant for voters as filling a cavity.In the days after his announcement of taking over the chancellorship of his alma mater, the University of Massachusetts at Lowell,… more
April 2, 2007

Panel picks radical voting changes for Ontario

The group charged with reviewing Ontario's voting system yesterday endorsed a model of German-style proportional representation as its preferred choice against the current system, a move that could radically alter the way MPPs are elected.

If the Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform recommends the system -- known as mixed… more

April 2, 2007

Elections Boards to consider Instant Runoff Voting

TARBORO – When Rocky Mount voters go to the polls this October to elect their city leaders, they may get more than one choice per race.

The Nash and Edgecombe County boards of elections are mulling a request from the state to make Rocky Mount one of 10 pilot cities… more

April 1, 2007

IRV on KPCC, Morning Edition

Lynne Serpe, Deputy Director of New America's Political Reform Program, presented information to Los Angeles' Ethics Commission on February 13, 2007 and again on March 20, 2007. She was joined by Los Angeles City Clerk Frank Martinez, who was asked to provide his perspective on the implementation of IRV and… more
March 22, 2007

Alternative Voting Systems Forum, April 26th

On behalf of the New America Foundation, the Pasadena League of Women Voters, Common Cause, Pasadena Weekly and Invest in PUSD Kids, you are invited to attend one of the most exciting political events of the year!

more
March 13, 2007

The Election That Wasn't

(The following piece was drafted as an example op-ed. Letters to the editor need to be much shorter)

The sound of hissing air leaking out of Los Angeles democracy is unmistakable. In the March 6 elections, only 7 percent of registered voters turned out to vote, the lowest in decades.… more

March 11, 2007

Instant Runoff Voting Fares Well

"Instant runoff voting" made its formal political debut Tuesday night in St. Paul, apparently winning backing in resolutions put to scores of DFL precinct caucuses across the city.

"We're really pleased, but not surprised, at the support," said Gena Berglund, a St. Paul lawyer who is spearheading the effort to… more

March 8, 2007

Dems Welcome Independent Voters

(Program Director Steven Hill is quoted in this piece in the San Francisco Chronicle article about California's presidential primary)

If California's independent voters want a voice in next year's presidential primary, they better start paying attention to Hillary Rodham Clinton, Barack Obama and the rest of the Democratic… more

March 7, 2007

A New Way to Vote?

Allowing voters at the polls to rank their choice of candidates rather than simply voting for one person sounds like an easy way to empower third-party candidates without putting them in a spoiler role. What hasn’t been answered, however, is how instant runoff voting would work in Maine.

If lawmakers… more

March 2, 2007

Democracy in America: One day, they may get it right

(Published in the Toronto Globe & Mail by Gordon Gibson of British Columbia) A conference in California last weekend gave new hope to U.S. democracy. While most American writings proclaim their democracy as the best, those sentiments are more patriotic than factual. The U.S.… more
February 28, 2007

New undergrad voting system may go to referendum

(Ranked voting is being used on college campuses across the county. This article by Nicholas Smith was published February 16th, 2007 in The McGill Daily)

No voting system is perfect, but Ross Margulies has a vision for a SSMU election system that he thinks can come closer.

Margulies, U3… more

February 17, 2007

Real Democracy…Or Dystopia?

(An excerpt from the final chapter of Steven Hill's "10 Steps to Repair American Democracy" was published at TomPaine.com)

 

Imagine that it is Election Day 2016. Imagine yet another presidential election that boils down to the same two battleground states—Ohio and… more

February 16, 2007

Takoma Park's New Vote System Makes Debut

(This article by Miranda Spivack was published February 8th 2007 in Washington Post) Takoma Park, among the first places in the country to label itself a nuclear-free zone, is once again in the vanguard of a political movement: instant runoff voting.

In… more

February 9, 2007

Instant runoff voting unveiled in Ward 5 election

Published February 7th 2007 in The GazetteBy Agnes Jasinski

While special elections are rare in Takoma Park, there was something even more unusual in how residents elected Reuben Snipper, their new Ward 5 councilman.This was the first time the city and the state used instant runoff voting (IRV), allowing… more
February 8, 2007

IRV lets voters rank candidates

(this article was published in the Trenton Times, February 5th 2007) Ralph Nader is back in the spotlight again. He's the subject of a new documentary film, "An Unreasonable Man." And he's making the rounds… more
February 6, 2007

US Senators Stress Bipartisanship

(This piece posted by Voice of America about New America's Ten Big Ideas event last week)

 

U.S. Senator Hillary Clinton, a Democrat from New York, and Senator Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South Carolina, were the keynote speakers at a conference this week unveiling a number of… more

February 4, 2007

Eliminating Runoffs

(Editorial in the Long Beach Press-Telegram explores IRV)

Long Beach voters will have about all they want to deal with in the way of charter amendments in the May 1 election, but here's one to consider foranother time: fewer elections. It's clear voters would appreciate it, as evidenced… more

January 28, 2007

Let's Give a Swift Kick to the Rumpocracy

(Opinion Piece by Steven Hill in the San Francisco Chronicle)

Californians and their state government are drifting further apart.

A recent poll by the Public Policy Institute of California found only 20 percent of November voters believe our state will be a better place to live in 2025;… more

January 28, 2007

Redistricting reform draws a map of great disappointment

(This piece by Mark Paul was published along-side the opinion piece by Steven Hill)

Political reform is what we do in California to break our hearts. We enact the initiative to take government away from the special interests, only to watch the initiative process turn into a… more

January 28, 2007

Steven Hill's "10 Steps to Repair American Democracy" reviewed in The Nation Magazine

(excerpt from "The Work Cut Out For Us" by George Scialabba)

We now have a bit of breathing space, thanks to the midterms. It's time to consider how the right got away with it and how to prevent it from happening again. The most useful of these books (along… more

January 19, 2007

Catching On to Instant Runoff Voting

Political reforms such as redistricting reform and campaign finance reform have foundered at the ballot box in recent years, rejected by voters in several states. But another political reform, instant runoff voting, has quietly racked up impressive victories.

Instant runoff voting (IRV), which allows voters to… more

January 15, 2007

Ford's Partisanship: How to Keep it Alive?

This piece was published on Sunday. It mentions instant runoff voting, Steven Hill, and is definitely worth a read.

WASHINGTON -- Can we make it last -- the wave of good feeling, bipartisanship, shared… more

January 8, 2007

'Instant runoff' voting touted

Oakland will use such a system. Davis, Calif., has opted for 'proportional representation.' Backers believe the systems make races more competitive.

SACRAMENTO - Americans have been picking politicians the same way for so long - winner take all - that it might seem there is no… more

December 26, 2006

The way forward for political reform

December 19, 2006 --As Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger renews his call for an independent redistricting commission, a new opinion poll finds that California voters overwhelmingly support improvements in the election process, but there's a catch -- it depends on who is proposing them.

A… more

December 20, 2006

Governor Should Ask Average Citizens, Not Politicians, to Make Elections More Fair

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: December 12, 2006

Contact: Steven Hill (415-6655044) or David Lesher (916-448-3721)

The poll analysis, survey question and results are available below in PDF format.

SACRAMENTO, CA – As… more

December 13, 2006

Governor Should Ask Average Citizens, Not Politicians, to Make Elections More Fair

A statewide survey commissioned by the New America Foundation showed overwhelming support for the idea of a Citizens Assembly. Read the full press release (excerpt below):

 

SACRAMENTO, CA – As Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger calls for more competition in elections, a survey… more

December 12, 2006

Democrats should make fairness a priority in Congress

With Democrats now in control of Congress for the first time in a dozen years, one way for Democrats to build faith with all Americans would be to pursue policies designed to increase fairness within Congress, as well as improve democracy in the United States. Change is… more

November 29, 2006

Pasadena City Council Tables Plan to Elect School Board Members Geographically

Lynne Serpe of the New America Foundation made a short pitch to the Pasadena City Council urging them to look into instant runoff voting or choice voting for electing members of the Pasadena Unified School District. Choice Voting was recommended by the Pasadena Charter Review Commission in 1997-1998 but… more

November 15, 2006

Cities Approve New Elections, Voting System

Instant Runoff Voting (IRV), an idea advanced by the New America Foundation, a Washington think tank, to give voters more influence and more choices in elections, continued to gain favor in California and elsewhere as four cities strongly approved Nov. 7 ballot measures supporting the idea, the foundation… more

November 14, 2006

Election Proves New Voting Method to Improve Democracy Is Catching On

Signature idea from New America is Adopted by Voters in Four Cities, Two in California

 

(SACRAMENTO, CA) -- Instant Runoff Voting (IRV), a signature idea from the New America Foundation to give voters more influence and more choices in elections, continued to gain favor in California and… more

November 13, 2006

Pierce County Voters Choose Instant Runoffs Over Pick-a-Party Primaries

Pierce County, WA voters were the first to consider the use of instant runoff voting in partisan elections. IRV elections would be conducted only for the offices of county executive, County Council, assessor and treasurer. Judges and prosecutors are considered officers of the state.

November 10, 2006

Better Ballot Campaign Receives 65 Percent Support

This question appeared on the general election ballot on November 7, 2006:

A PROPOSAL TO USE INSTANT RUNOFF VOTING IN MINNEAPOLIS ELECTIONS

Should the City of Minneapolis adopt Single Transferable Vote, sometimes known as Ranked Choice Voting or Instant Runoff Voting, as the method for electing the Mayor,… more

November 10, 2006

Davis Advisory Vote Sends Clear Message

The Davis advisory vote on ranked choice voting sends a strong message to the local council -- that Davis voters are interested in change, and want to see the council move forward in improving the system of electing local representatives.

November 10, 2006

Oakland Passes Measure O with 68 Percent Voter Support

Oakland voters join San Francisco and Berkeley voters in passing instant runoff voting -- sometimes known as ranked choice voting -- for use in local elections. Instant runoff voting (IRV) would mean one election, not two, in November when turnout is highest.

November 9, 2006

Mail-Order Democracy

Program Director Steven Hill had an excellent article/opinion piece published in the Los Angeles Times on November 5th:

(Excerpt) All across California, millions of voters didn’t wait for election day. They didn’t hear any of the last-minute appeals from the candidates. They made up their minds weeks ago and filled… more

November 6, 2006

Davis Voters Asked to Support Measure L

Davis voters will be asked to follow the recent lead of University of Davis students, and change the way they elect their local representatives. The New America Foundation sponsored an educational forum on Measure L and Choice Voting on Friday, October 27th from 7-9pm in Council Chambers, City Hall.… more

October 20, 2006

Minneapolis Looking at Better Ballots

The Better Ballot Campaign argues that ranked choice voting will fix many of Minneapolis' current election problems by accomplishing several rounds of elections with just one easy-to-use ballot. Only 15% of registered Minneapolis voters turned out for the 2005 primary, a problem the city is hoping… more

October 19, 2006

Oakland Prepares for Instant Runoffs

The Yes on O campaign to improve Oakland elections with instant runoff voting is going strong. Placed on the ballot with a July 18 city council vote, Measure O aims to replace the city's June primary and November runoff with one high-turnout majority election. Enodrsers of Measure… more

October 10, 2006

National Direct Election of the President is Good for California

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has sitting on his desk a bill that he ought to sign. Signing AB 2948 would establish California as a national leader in the effort to create a nationwide popular vote for president, which recent elections have shown would be a more democratic method than the 18th… more

September 29, 2006

America’s Increasing Democracy Deficit

In the post-World War II period, America was seen by many as the "City on the Hill," an imperfect yet nonetheless shining beacon of government of, by, and for the people. But President George W. Bush’s harsh criticisms of The New York Times and other media outlets for their reporting… more

September 2, 2006

The Cuba Connection

Fidel Castro’s recent intestinal surgery led to a level of coverage in the US media usually reserved for rock stars and champion athletes. What is this fascination with the ruler of a small island nation? Is it the tempestuous cold war history, Cuba’s close proximity to Florida, memories of the… more

September 1, 2006

Will Your Vote County in 2006?

Watching Mexico live through a controversial presidential election was like holding up a mirror to our own election difficulties in recent years. As we round the corner and head toward the upcoming November elections -- with control of the Congress up for grabs -- what can Americans expect? Will our… more

August 2, 2006

Election Security 2006

Will your vote count on Tuesday? As we head into another election season -- with control of Congress potentially up for grabs -- ongoing concerns about voting equipment and election administration continue to worry fair elections advocates. Recent headlines have added to previous fears, but there are also signs that… more

June 5, 2006

Palestinian Elections: It's the Voting System, Stupid!

Much hand wringing and second guessing have been produced from the recent Palestinian elections that resulted in Hamas, a group on the Bush administration's terrorist list, winning a sizable majority of legislative seats. Analysts on the right and left have scrambled for a response, with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice… more

June 1, 2006

10 Steps to Repair American Democracy

Drawing upon the author’s 20 years of scholarship, advocacy, and two previous books, and including a trenchant foreword by The New Yorker's Hendrik Hertzberg, 10 Steps to Repair American Democracy is a "onestop" shopping guide to what's broken about our democracy, and what Americans can do to repair it.

more
May 30, 2006