In the News

New America Foundation in the Sacramento Bee on Growing Political Middle

Disconnect Shown Anew in Election
December 3, 2006

Last month's election provided new evidence that while politicians from the two major parties fight their shrill ideological battles -- egged on by radio and cable television talkers -- they represent ever-shrinking constituencies and thus are becoming increasingly disconnected from the larger society.

The political middle, disenchanted with the confrontational and ultimately meaningless tone of contemporary politics, has been growing. The number of voters who register as Republicans or Democrats in California has remained unchanged for a decade and a half while the ranks of independent voters have swelled to nearly a fifth of the total...

That's why, for instance, California's two major parties, which agree on practically nothing in the policy realm, joined arms to successfully challenge voter-approved open primary elections. Open primaries would allow cross-party voters and independents to make decisions on party nominees, thereby threatening the stranglehold of liberal Democrats and conservative Republicans on their parties' dynamics.

And that's why leaders of the two major parties in the Legislature conspired after the 2000 census to redraw 173 legislative and congressional districts to designate each district's party ownership, minimize interparty competition and make the closed party primary the vehicle for electing officeholders...

Opening up California's political process by breaking up the partisan monopoly is not rocket science. Shifting redistricting from politicians to an independent commission, reinstating the open primary, removing the legal barriers to independent candidates, using "instant runoff voting" rather than winner-take-all for some offices, and divvying up legislative seats proportionately are all proposals to bring more small-d democracy to the process.

Think tanks and independent foundations such as the Irvine Foundation and the New America Foundation are making noise about reform, but there's a potentially fatal Catch-22. State legislators won't embrace reforms that threaten their own power, and groups with vested interests in the status quo would spend lavishly to defeat reforms on the ballot.

For the complete article, please visit the Sacramento Bee website.



See all New America articles, appearances & citations from The Sacramento Bee