Too Small to Fail
With the big guns in the financial services industry in turmoil, it’s a
good time to ask hard questions about the nature of our finance system.
Does bigger always mean better? Or does small-scale "relationship"
banking, in which individual savers and borrowers are members of the
same community, help to make a better banking sector? Community banks
and credit unions were regarded until recently as vestigial players in
a new world of global consumer finance. But today they aren’t merely
doing well; they also seem to have a lot to offer.
On November 20th, New America and the Washington Monthly explored ways to encourage the health and number of small-scale
financial institutions as a means of thwarting the tendency toward
excessive consolidation in financial services and restoring a mutuality
of interest between borrowers and lenders. By encouraging thrift,
responsibility, and a sense of community, small-scale financial
institutions could play a leading role in digging out from the current
recession and avoiding the next one.
A new paper in New America's "Big Ideas" Series and a feature article in the Nov. 19th Washington Monthly both explore this question in detail. Copies will be available at this event.
For video of this event, click here.
About Us
Getting ahead in today’s economy depends not just on one’s job and income, but increasingly on one’s ability to accumulate and utilize assets -- to buy a home, pay for higher education, start a business or save for retirement. Yet more than half of all Americans currently have few or no assets for investment. The Asset Building Program advances innovative policies -- such as a “Homestead Act” for the 21st century that would provide every American child financial assets from birth -- to significantly expand economic opportunity, thereby giving all Americans a personal stake in the overall success of our economy.
More information about the program is available here.
Answers to FAQs about assets and current asset statistics are available at www.assetbuilding.org
Articles
| Article | Date |
|---|---|
| What We Need Out of a Second Stimulus Package | October 22, 2008 |
| Too Small To Fail | October 21, 2008 |
| Pay to Learn is Working in New York | October 15, 2008 |
| How to Encourage Families to Save for College | September 25, 2008 |
| Tax Refunds Deposited onto Prepaid Cards Could Provide Financial Access to Unbanked | September 23, 2008 |
| Breaking Asset Poverty | September 16, 2008 |
| Paying City Students Is a Wise Investment | June 27, 2008 |
| Wheels Versus Welfare | June 19, 2008 |
| Making a Transaction and Savings Account a Certainty, Just Like Taxes | May 22, 2008 |
| Don't Spend Your Tax Rebate! | April 15, 2008 |
Policy Papers
| Title | Date |
|---|---|
| To Save America's Finances, Bring Back Community Banking | November 2008 |
| Financial Education in the Workplace | November 2008 |
| AutoSave Concept Paper | November 2008 |
| Autosave Pilot Overview | November 2008 |
| Rental Assistance Asset Accounts | October 2008 |
| The Effectiveness of Youth Financial Education | October 2008 |
| Descriptive Bibliography | October 2008 |
| Behaviorally Informed Financial Services Regulation | October 2008 |
| Saver’s Bonus Act (S. 3372) | October 2008 |
| SAFE-T Accounts | October 2008 |
Events
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Too Small to Fail | November 20, 2008 |
| Foreclosures: What are Fannie And Freddie Doing to Stem the Tide? | November 13, 2008 |
| CA EVENT: Turning Crisis into Opportunity | November 6, 2008 |
| CA EVENT: Strengthening California’s Workforce through Education, Training, and Savings | October 20, 2008 |
| Regulating to Avoid the Next Financial Crisis | October 17, 2008 |
| CA Event: ScholarShare: Expanding Savings for Higher Education and Skills Training | September 30, 2008 |
| Global Savings, Assets and Financial Inclusion | July 30, 2008 |
| CA Event: Microenterprise Development | July 21, 2008 |
| CA Event: Expanding Savings and Retirement Security | May 21, 2008 |
| Confronting the Debt Culture | May 12, 2008 |
Press
Staff
- Ray Boshara
Vice President and Director, Asset Building Program - Olivia Calderon
California Legislative Director - Reid Cramer
Research Director - Mark Huelsman
Program Associate - Justin King
Federal Policy Liaison - Melissa Koide
Deputy Director - Phillip Longman
Schwartz Senior Fellow - Alejandra Lopez-Fernandini
Policy Analyst - Karen Murrell
Senior Research Fellow - David Newville
Policy Analyst - Rourke O'Brien
Research Fellow - Mark Paul
Senior Scholar - Ellen Seidman
Director, Financial Services Policy - Leila Seradj
Program Associate, Global Assets Project - Fred Ssewamala
Senior Research Fellow, Global Assets Project
- Anne Stuhldreher
Fellow
- Jamie Zimmerman
Deputy Director, Global Assets Project
Click on any name above for additional information.
Presentations
- No, CRA Didn't Cause the Current Financial Crisis!
- Ellen Seidman; 11/5/2008; Washington, DC
- Asset Building Strategies for Domestic Violence Survivors
- Alejandra Lopez-Fernandini; 11/4/2008; Washington, DC
- Financial Education in the Workplace
- Lewis Mandell; 9/26/2008; Webinar
- Federal Policies to Encourage Savings and Accounts at Tax Time
- Melissa Koide; 9/13/2008; Washington, DC
- U.S. Savings Bonds: America's Best Kept Secret
- Melissa Koide; 9/12/2008; Washington, DC
- Asset Building and Low-Income Families
- Reid Cramer; 9/12/2008; Washington, DC
- Assets in the Workplace
- Ellen Seidman; 9/11/2008; Washington, DC
- Developing Sophisticated Financial Consumers
- Karen Murrell; 9/10/2008; Washington, DC
- Homeownership in a New Era
- Ellen Seidman; 6/4/08; Los Angeles, CA
- Savings and Asset Building: Global Lessons, Trends, Challenges and Opportunities
- Jamie Zimmerman; 8/27/2008; Hanoi, Vietnam
- Financial System Regulation: Testimony Before the Joint Economic Committee
- Ellen Seidman; 5/14/08; Washington, DC
- 529 College Savings Plans, Testimony Submitted for the Hearing on "Education Tax Incentives"
- Reid Cramer; 5/1/08; Washington, DC
- Financial Literacy: Need, Strategies, Opportunity
- Ellen Seidman; 4/17/08; California Assets Forum, Sacramento, CA
- Policy Approaches for Saving and Asset Building by Low-Income Americans
- Ray Boshara; 03/19/08; FDIC, Washington DC
- Optimal Capital Structure: The Role of Savings in MFIs
- Ellen Seidman; 2/21/08; Women's World Banking, Westchester, NY
- Next Generation CRA: A 21st Century Responsibility and Accountability Agenda for Consumer Financial Services
- Ellen Seidman; 10/24/07; Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, Washington, DC
- Asset Building: Catholic Social Thought and a New Strategy for Helping the Poor
- Ray Boshara; 02/15/07; Catholic University, Washington DC
- Savings and Asset Development for the Poor in Developing Countries
- Ray Boshara; 01/23/07; The World Bank, Washington DC
- Children's Savings Accounts; Forum on Building Wealth for the Next Generation
- Ray Boshara; 10/11/06; Puerto Rico
- The U.S. Experience with Asset-Building Policies and Programs
- Ray Boshara; 06/19/06; HRSD Roundtable, Ottawa, Canada
- Asset Building: The Path to Financial Independence for Women
- Ray Boshara; 10/26/05; Women’s Policy, Inc. & Congressional Women’s Caucus, Washington DC
- The Perils and Promise of An “Ownership Society”
- Ray Boshara; 06/22/05; Federal Reserve Bank; Cleveland, OH
- The “Ownership Society” and Social Policy in the 2nd Bush Administration
- Ray Boshara; 01/14/05; Tokyo America Center, Tokyo, Japan
- OECD Forum on Mexico: Policies to Promote Growth and Economic Development
- Ray Boshara; 11/03/04; Mexico City, Mexico
- IDAs and Asset Building: Some Lessons and Observations on the Future
- Ray Boshara; 06/22/04; Building the Financial Futures of Working Families, Chicago, IL
Foreclosures: What are Fannie and Freddie Doing to Stem the Tide?
On September 7, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were placed into conservatorship. There was an expectation that the move would make the companies, which had hunkered down to preserve capital, much more active in dealing with the on-going housing crisis. What has actually happened, and what are the prospects for the future? On November 13th, the Asset Building Program hosted a panel of experts featuring James Lockhart -- Director and Chairman of the Oversight Board of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, regulator of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the 12 Federal Home Loan Banks -- that discussed these and other questions relating to the conservatorship. Also featured were Barry Zigas of the Consumer Federation of America and Gregory Baer of Bank of America. The event was moderated by Ellen Seidman, Financial Services Policy Director in the Asset Building Program at the New America Foundation. Video of the entire event is available here.
Below is a brief discussion between James Lockhart and Ellen Seidman on the conservatorship of Fannie and Freddie.
Regulating to Avoid the Next Financial Crisis
A new approach to the way we write the rules for buying homes, getting credit cards and managing our finances is needed, one based on real-world human behavior, not just economic theory. Regulations governing these transactions can play an extremely constructive role if they are better attuned to both consumers' and producers' behavior, incentives and self-interest. On October 17, the Asset Building Program published a seminal paper and on this timely topic by Professors Michael Barr of the University of Michigan Law School, Sendhil Mullainathan of Harvard University, and Eldar Shafir of Princeton University entitled Behaviorally Informed Financial Services Regulation.
Using the tools of behavioral economics, Professors Barr, Mullainathan and Shafir-- three of the nation's leaders in this field-- propose that regulators should pay attention to both the "rules of the game"--what a provider must do or say, and the "scoring"-the reward or penalty arising from obeying or ignoring the rules. Based on this novel framework, the authors propose ten innovative ideas for regulating mortgages, credit cards and bank accounts for saving.
Also on October 17th, Professors Barr and Shafir, as well as Alex Pollock of the American Enterprise Institute and Travis Plunkett of Consumer Federation of America, gave a lively discussion on these topics, moderated by David Wessel of the Wall Street Journal. To watch the video of the event, click here.
Below is a short interview between Ellen Seidman and Professors Barr and Shafir:
Senator Menendez (D-NJ) Introduces Saver's Bonus Act
The Saver's Bonus Act was introduced on July 31st by Senator Robert Menendez. By providing a match at tax time for savings, the Saver's Bonus simplifies and eases eligible families' ability to save and build wealth through a number of short- middle- and long-term savings products. For more information about the Saver's Bonus, click here.
The Assets Agenda
The newest edition of New America's Assets Agenda outlines a federal public policy agenda to broaden savings and asset ownership opportunities for lower-income Americans who have limited resources at their disposal. This edition is the most comprehensive to date, with 84 innovative asset-building ideas. To read this paper, click here.




