Smaller Legislative Districts = Better Representation
One of the most exciting things about the California Constitutional Convention Summit that The New America Foundation is co-sponsoring with the Bay Area Council next Tuesday is that it has the potential to act as a channel for focusing and combining the efforts of different political reform campaigns.
Many of these have similar goals but are operating on parallel tracks.
For example, last fall Mark Paul and I drafted a proposal to radically reorder California legislative elections into a system of region-based proportional representation. One element of this plan was increasing the size of the state legislature from 120 representatives in two houses to 360 in one unicameral body.
At the very same time, a California voter named Michael Warnken was filing a detailed brief in a federal court in Sacramento. His suit claims that the massive size of California's legislative districts - greater than 400,000 people for each seat in the lower house - constitutes grossly inadequate and hence illegally poor representation for the state's citizens. At a hearing last month, a federal judge refused to dismiss the case. You can find out more about his efforts here at his site, California Commonwealth.
With Californians competing with almost half a million of their fellow citizens to get the attention even of the members of the State Assembly, how can their voices be heard?
- Login to post comments


















Michael Warnken Responds
He writes:
Representation is so important because it is the issue that most centrally affects all other issues. Your colleague, Mark Paul touched on just one of the important issues and that is oversight. They are many others on top of that.
In any event, I appreciate your interest in my work and I really appreciate your paper. You certainly made the proposal independent of me and my work and you did take the stance of thinking outside the box. Work like yours is another source willing to say, "What we have is not adequate!" That is the truth, 80 is not enough. The question may come down to "What is proper?"
Did you know there are more Federal Judges inCalifornia than Assembly members? There are 164 Federal Judges not including Magistrate Judges and 80 Assembly members. Over and over, I make the point that I have better access to the Federal courts than my own legislature. This is simply wrong and it is why the Federal courts are taking over the prisons and all other aspects of Government. They have capacity to oversee whereas the legislative reps are taking donations from the state employees and cannot possibly hold them accountable and there are too few.