Blockbuster Democracy - logo
 

The Home of William Tell

September 28, 2008 - 12:06pm
if Swiss direct democracy has a Mt. Olympus, this may be it. Altdorf, where I'm spending the night, is the capital of the tiny canton -- that's what the Swiss call their states -- of Uri, in the center of the country. It's also the hometown of William Tell, Swiss hero. One caveat: It's not a mountain really. Altdorf is in  a narrow valley, with steep, sometimes sheer moutains on each side. It put me in mind of the Yosemite Valley.

This may be the most direct democratic part of the world's most advanced direct democracy. Uri has just 35,000 people, 25,000 of them eligible to vote. It was one of the original three Swiss cantons, dating to 1291. (Tell, in a popular founding myth that has little historical authenticity, shot the Austrian overlord of Uri with a crossbow in 1307). As we arrived in town, election returns showed a flat tax referendum passing at the ballot, along with another measure. Next, the canton's voters will consider an initaitive to lower the voting age to 16. (A nearby Canton has moved to do the same). The idea was advanced by a group of young socialists here, but Canton justice minister Heidi Z'graggen, when I asked her why the canton would consider such a change, replied, "Why not?" She also suggested that such a measure might "balance" a voting population that skews old. This all came in an exchange with myself and other reporters during which the minister, a Christian Democrat, described herself as "very conservative." The former California state senator, John Vasconcellos, was mocked for his liberalism when he pushed similar legislation in Sacramento.

This place makes direct democracy so easy that there aren't paid signature gatherers or other political pros (Consultants and paid gatherers are very much present in more populous areas such as Bern and Zurich). It takes just 450 signatures to qualify a referendum for the ballot here, and 600 signatures to qualify an initaitive.

That's all for now. More tomorrow when I head to the Swiss federal capital, Bern.

Why Not?

The Justice Minister's comment is revealing:
1. If the 16-year voting age doesn't work out, it can be easily changed again, either by legislation or initiative. The balance of power between Parliament and people keeps things fluid and changeable; natural and lively. Here in the U.S., gerrymandering and buying Congress has made things constipated and rotten. For example, Congress has dithered about national health insurance since the '40s, while every other Western country got it and our nation's health has fallen to 37th in the world, between Costa Rica and Slovenia!
2.It seems even old and "conservative" people in Switzerland aren't afraid of the young. Maybe that's because power there isn't ruining the future, turning kids into resentful enemies.
Although I made good money passing initiative petitions (only for things I believe in) I'd be glad to be out of a job in order to live in a country that is moving forward rather than leading the world to a climatic and political hell.

Post new comment

Please note that comments are reviewed by an editor prior to publication. We welcome all relevant critiques, feedback and counterarguments, but comments that are profane, offensive, off-topic or blatantly commercial will not be published.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for weeding out automated spam submissions.