Don't Lie In Arizona
Watch out, John McCain. It is now a crime to lie while discussing politics in the state of Arizona. Of course, this new law applies not to politicians, city or state officials, or anyone in a position of authority. The criminalizing of lying is limited to only that most powerful of people: signature gatherers.
This legislation, recently signed into law by Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano, is pure madness. Who will decide who is lying and who is not? Probably judges and elected officials who don't like whatever petition the gatherers are circulating. What's next? Do circulators have to travel with lawyers? Perhaps we need legislation requiring circulators to tape all their conversations, like detectives must do when defendatns are confessing?
Lying is part of politics. Fraud by signature gatherers -- faking names, faking signatures -- should be prosecuted criminally and fiercely. And yes, signature gatherers should be honest in how they describe petitions. But any criminal law governing the subject will be, at best, selectively enforced. The right to petition your government is fundamental in any free society. Take it away, and people will seek other, more destructive ways to change things they don't like. In the end, the voters who sign petitions must be responsible for what they sign.


















If it is a crime for me to
If it is a crime for me to sign a petition with a false name and address (and it is), then it should be a crime for a signature-gatherer to lie to me about what I'm signing.
Don't blame Janet
Don't blame Napolitano, although she should not have signed this in to law.
Blame Jan Brewer, the Secretary of State. This maven of un-democracy is one to watch when it comes to undermining public participation.
She pushed this law because she did not like a particular initiative that was being circulated (it created more competitive state and legislative districts).
The beauty of it is that the language in the law is so broad and silly that certainly some initiative that she favors will be thrown out because the signature gatherers were not honest. Case in point: the "civil liberties" initiative pushed by Ward Connerly is really hiding an anti-affirmative action initiative. Shouldn't they say that?
This woman hopes to be governor some day!
Post new comment